Saturday, November 20, 2010

Unconscious Bias of Australian Selectors

If we assume for a moment that the Australian selectors are making decisions that they consider the best for Australian cricket, and not merely to piss me off (and I am not yet convinced of this argument, but anyway), I wonder whether there is an unconscious bias towards batsmen.

Recently, Australian cricket has been plagued by batting collapses, and an underperforming middle order. North and Hussey in particular have been considered by most judges (other than the selectors) to be under pressure to hold their places for over 12 months. However, in spite of losing our last three tests, the only change (other than the return from injury by Haddin) that appears likely for the first Test is the dropping of Hauritz (and potentially Bollinger evidently).

While I don't think Hauritz should be anywhere near our national team, why is a bowler the sole victim of our recent poor form? Haurie's form against India was crap, but he was actually better than expected last summer. Why does his two failures in India result in his dropping, whereas Hussey's three years of underperforming doesn't similarly result in demotion?

If you look at the composition of the panel, all are former batsmen. I wonder whether they are, perhaps unconsciously, more sympathetic to the plight of struggling batsmen than bowlers? Would a selection panel made up of Shane Warne, Geoff Lawson, Terry Alderman and Merv Hughes (hypothetically) been as likely to drop a bowler as our current group? Should there be a better balance between former batsmen and bowlers on the national panel, as there appears to be both currently and historically a strong trend towards former batsmen being selectors rather than bowlers.

47 comments:

Anonymous said...

Pretty nice post. I just stumbled upon your blog and wanted to say that I have really enjoyed browsing your blog posts. In any case I’ll be subscribing to your feed and I hope you write again soon!

Anonymous said...

[url=http://infobooksonline.com/shop/College+Textbooks/]College Textbooks[/url]. Accounting Books, Biology, Database Systems, Essentials of Economics, Law Books, Microbiology, Organic Chemistry.

Anonymous said...

Great, i found what i 've been lookin for

Anonymous said...

Gladys is the greatest!


http://hobby-insurance.info

Anonymous said...

Hi, i just want to say hello to the community

ICLfan said...

Hi, Wish you a happy new year...

You have my blog link on your blogrool list (CRICKET FAN INDIA> cricket-fan-india.blogspot.com). First of all thanks for keeping that for this long on your blog list. On my blog i am concentrating on the cricket world cup 2011. and would like to request to change the test to "Cricket World Cup 2011 Online" from "Cricket Fan India". Of course if this doesn't bother you....have a nice day ahead.

Iclfan.

Steve said...

Search for Cricket champions, pictures, photo, cricket media of cricketer biography and pictures in http://cricket-champions-pictures.blogspot.com/

Anonymous said...

Thanks for this wonderful post.Admiring the time and effort you put into your blog and detailed information you offer..

DesiGujju said...

Watch Live SETMAX 100% & watch All Pakistani & Indian Tv Channels 100% Updated n working Free on
www.nowwatchtvlive.com
www.nowwatchtvlive.com
www.nowwatchtvlive.com

DesiGujju said...

Watch Live USA Channels,MUsic Channels,Sports Channels Sky Sports, ESPN, Star Cricket, Ten Cricket, Eurosports HD, Al-Jazeera Sports, ESPN America, ESPN U HD and lots of many more @
www.nowwatchtvlive.com
www.nowwatchtvlive.com
www.nowwatchtvlive.com

Jitendra Rawal said...

Watch Live Cricket matches online , IPl, Champions league, matches live India , pakistan, australia, england, srilanka, west indies, bangladesh all channels working at
http://www.onlinetvjunction.com
http://www.onlinetvjunction.com
http://www.onlinetvjunction.com

Desi-times said...

Desi-times.blogspot.com
Desi-times.blogspot.com
Desi-times.blogspot.com
Desi-times.blogspot.com
Desi-times.blogspot.com

ren tv said...

EloanTV.com
EloanTV.com
EloanTV.com
EloanTV.com

Vioxxtv.blogspot.com
Vioxxtv.blogspot.com
Vioxxtv.blogspot.com
Vioxxtv.blogspot.com

Anonymous said...

The cricket in England is being played since 16th century and is considered as England’s national summer sport. The England and Wales Cricket Board (ECB) is the governing body of England and Wales, Created on 1st January 1997. England team having Test cricket status and One Day International status, and is also Twenty-20 playing nation. England Played first Test match in 1877 and first One Day International in 1971 both against Australia in Melbourne.

List of England cricketers are:
Alec Stewart,
Graham Gooch,
David Gower,
Mike Atherton,
Colin Cowdrey,
Geoff Boycott,
Ian Botham,
Graham Thorpe, i found it here friends !!
http://www.cricinfy.com/England-cricket-facts-history-future-achivements.html

kaney said...

The unconscious mind is a sad, saintly, and very serious doctor who protects your mental health from craziness and terror. The absurdity you have inherited into the biggest part of your brain is very dangerous. It can destroy your life. Therefore, when you try to understand the symbolic words of your unconscious doctor, you must have in mind that you are having a serious conversation with your psychiatrist because your mental health is in danger.

ostaderm v

Roxanna said...

The author is absolutely right, and there is no question.

Muhammad Hussain said...

The Top Most Expensive Cars in the World, Top Speed Cars, Top most hot cars pictures and info
worldlatestvehicles.blogspot.com

Anonymous said...

how to buy priligy UK [url=https://flavors.me/googlegavno#7i2c]kamagra online[/url] [url=https://flavors.me/nadobabla#1a8m]priligy no rx[/url] cheap plavix cost gvh plavix pills price don zithromax priligy without prescription clomid atarax price uk ecb

Anonymous said...

how to buy priligy UK [url=https://flavors.me/googlegavno#7i2c]kamagra online[/url] [url=https://flavors.me/nadobabla#1a8m]priligy no rx[/url] cheap plavix cost gvh plavix pills price don zithromax priligy without prescription clomid atarax price uk ecb

Anonymous said...

how to buy priligy UK [url=https://flavors.me/googlegavno#7i2c]kamagra online[/url] [url=https://flavors.me/nadobabla#1a8m]priligy no rx[/url] cheap plavix cost gvh plavix pills price don zithromax priligy without prescription clomid atarax price uk ecb

Deepak Gupta said...

packers and movers bangalore
packers and movers pune
packers and movers chennai
packers and movers hyderabad
packers and movers gurgaon
packers and movers chandigarh
packers and movers lucknow
packers and movers mumbai

Orange County Chiropractor said...

Huntington Beach Chiropractor diagnose encompass fracture, nerve problems, tumor, implant issues and serious injuries. Recognized as a health care profession, chiropractic care is effective treatment to dwindle acute back pains. It is suitable and beneficial to folks who wish to maintain healthy spine for protracted time.

Kamao Poot said...

Find best Home based Business without any work, just invest and rest with your profit
EarningsClub.com

will kenderdine said...

Excellent site! When you have time grab a peek at my site too… : ) http://isee-ato.com

will kenderdine said...

Friends, sales interview questions with critical insights to your new selling role are my greatest strength uncovered across all my online portals that you need to read today:
http://www.amazon.com/Knock-Dead-Job-Interview-Interviews/dp/1440536791

Nikx Fabrizio said...

Watch free Sports Channels online | USA Tv Channels | UK Tv Channels | Other Tv Channels | Watch USA Tv Series online | Live Stream Free | Watch High Quality Live Streaming online

Daily Event Schedule | Sport Schedule | NFL, NHL, RUGBY, HOCKEY, SKIING, GRAND PRIX NASCAR | Daily Tv Shows Schedule | Comedy Shows, Drama, Sci Fi | Mystery | Action

Watch USA, UK, AUS, Canada Tv Series Live Streams and HD Recaps online for free.

vetrafurniture said...

I am sure, it's good that he's reaching out to you when he's worried rather than bottling it all up. But how stressful for you. http://worldcricketprofiles.com/

cricket said...

Thank you very much for the valuable information
I have researched a lot about the cricket
At this site got a very excellent information

Nikhil Padwal said...

Please visit this blog for more interesting facts about cricket - http://cricketthefirstlove.blogspot.in/

Anonymous said...

http://cricinfovalley.blogspot.com/

Friv4 said...

When you're tired, you want to relax after a stressful working hours, you need to have time to take care of the kids active.
Please visit our website and play exciting flash games.
Thanks you for sharing!
Friv 4

chetna gupta said...

Nice one. You people can take help from the latest sport news to know what are the things going on these days in your favorite sports without making things really impressive and effective for those who love to know about sports as they are their favorite past time.

akbar badshah said...


Watch live cricket streaming of current matches on crictime . It fulfil all the needs of viewers they can watch live cricket streaming, get ball by ball scorecards updates, result and highlights of the match. Crictime is one of the best source of watching live cricket.

PTV Sports said...

Thanks for your marvelous posting! I seriously enjoyed reading it, you will be a great author.
I will make sure to bookmark your blog and may come
back later in life. I want to encourage continue your great posts,
have a nice evening!


CONACACAF Live
Pakistan vs India Live

Anonymous said...

Nice Article
Willow TV Live
DD National Live Streaming
Pakistan vs India Final Highlights
PTV Sports Biss Key

Star Sports Live Cricket said...

I love this blogspot because due to nice artivle
India vs Pakistan Video Highlights
Today Match Highlighta
Crictime Live India vs Pakistan
India vs Pakistan Final Live

Ahmed Ali said...

Hotstar Live Cricket
India vs Pakistan Live Streaming Final
India vs Pakistan Live Hotstar
India vs Pakistan Live Stream
Pakistan vs India Live Stream


Anonymous said...

Nice point of view admin
WWE Mitb 2017 Live
WWE Money in The Bank 2017 Live
Money in the Bank 2017 En Vivo

roth phallyka said...

i just want to say hello to the community


Goldenslot

Sports GEO said...

Such a great Post!! Thanks For Sharing. Are you looking to buy your first Leather Ball? It’s all available at just a click:Leather Balls

exam said...

wimbledon final

exam said...

Concacaf Gold Cup 2017 Final

exam said...

Happy Friendship Day 2017

exam said...

https://rakhirakshabandhan2017.in/

Vijay Kumar said...

Thanks Admin for making easy to this, we love to write on these topics – you can check
Happy Raksha Bandhan
Happy Raksha Bandhan 2017
Raksha Bandhan 2017
Raksha Bandhan Images
Happy Raksha Bandhan Images
Happy Friendship Day
Happy Friendship Day 2017
Friendship Day 2017
Friendship Day Images
Happy Friendship Day Images

Unknown said...


I am really impressed and happy with your work as you are motivating people to do something special for those who are near them. I love the concept and want to thank you for taking initiative. Keep posting and keep motivating. May god bless you.

Bluehost Discount Coupons

Unknown said...

Download WCL Mining Sirdar Admit Card

Download PNRD Assam Accredited Engineer Admit Card 2017