Saturday, November 20, 2010

Unconscious Bias of Australian Selectors

If we assume for a moment that the Australian selectors are making decisions that they consider the best for Australian cricket, and not merely to piss me off (and I am not yet convinced of this argument, but anyway), I wonder whether there is an unconscious bias towards batsmen.

Recently, Australian cricket has been plagued by batting collapses, and an underperforming middle order. North and Hussey in particular have been considered by most judges (other than the selectors) to be under pressure to hold their places for over 12 months. However, in spite of losing our last three tests, the only change (other than the return from injury by Haddin) that appears likely for the first Test is the dropping of Hauritz (and potentially Bollinger evidently).

While I don't think Hauritz should be anywhere near our national team, why is a bowler the sole victim of our recent poor form? Haurie's form against India was crap, but he was actually better than expected last summer. Why does his two failures in India result in his dropping, whereas Hussey's three years of underperforming doesn't similarly result in demotion?

If you look at the composition of the panel, all are former batsmen. I wonder whether they are, perhaps unconsciously, more sympathetic to the plight of struggling batsmen than bowlers? Would a selection panel made up of Shane Warne, Geoff Lawson, Terry Alderman and Merv Hughes (hypothetically) been as likely to drop a bowler as our current group? Should there be a better balance between former batsmen and bowlers on the national panel, as there appears to be both currently and historically a strong trend towards former batsmen being selectors rather than bowlers.

14 comments:

Anonymous said...

Pretty nice post. I just stumbled upon your blog and wanted to say that I have really enjoyed browsing your blog posts. In any case I’ll be subscribing to your feed and I hope you write again soon!

Anonymous said...

[url=http://infobooksonline.com/shop/College+Textbooks/]College Textbooks[/url]. Accounting Books, Biology, Database Systems, Essentials of Economics, Law Books, Microbiology, Organic Chemistry.

Anonymous said...

Great, i found what i 've been lookin for

Anonymous said...

Gladys is the greatest!


http://hobby-insurance.info

Anonymous said...

Hi, i just want to say hello to the community

ICLfan said...

Hi, Wish you a happy new year...

You have my blog link on your blogrool list (CRICKET FAN INDIA> cricket-fan-india.blogspot.com). First of all thanks for keeping that for this long on your blog list. On my blog i am concentrating on the cricket world cup 2011. and would like to request to change the test to "Cricket World Cup 2011 Online" from "Cricket Fan India". Of course if this doesn't bother you....have a nice day ahead.

Iclfan.

Steve said...

Search for Cricket champions, pictures, photo, cricket media of cricketer biography and pictures in http://cricket-champions-pictures.blogspot.com/

Anonymous said...

Thanks for this wonderful post.Admiring the time and effort you put into your blog and detailed information you offer..

DesiGujju said...

Watch Live SETMAX 100% & watch All Pakistani & Indian Tv Channels 100% Updated n working Free on
www.nowwatchtvlive.com
www.nowwatchtvlive.com
www.nowwatchtvlive.com

DesiGujju said...

Watch Live USA Channels,MUsic Channels,Sports Channels Sky Sports, ESPN, Star Cricket, Ten Cricket, Eurosports HD, Al-Jazeera Sports, ESPN America, ESPN U HD and lots of many more @
www.nowwatchtvlive.com
www.nowwatchtvlive.com
www.nowwatchtvlive.com

Jitendra Rawal said...

Watch Live Cricket matches online , IPl, Champions league, matches live India , pakistan, australia, england, srilanka, west indies, bangladesh all channels working at
http://www.onlinetvjunction.com
http://www.onlinetvjunction.com
http://www.onlinetvjunction.com

Desi-times said...

Desi-times.blogspot.com
Desi-times.blogspot.com
Desi-times.blogspot.com
Desi-times.blogspot.com
Desi-times.blogspot.com

ren tv said...

EloanTV.com
EloanTV.com
EloanTV.com
EloanTV.com

Vioxxtv.blogspot.com
Vioxxtv.blogspot.com
Vioxxtv.blogspot.com
Vioxxtv.blogspot.com

Anonymous said...

The cricket in England is being played since 16th century and is considered as England’s national summer sport. The England and Wales Cricket Board (ECB) is the governing body of England and Wales, Created on 1st January 1997. England team having Test cricket status and One Day International status, and is also Twenty-20 playing nation. England Played first Test match in 1877 and first One Day International in 1971 both against Australia in Melbourne.

List of England cricketers are:
Alec Stewart,
Graham Gooch,
David Gower,
Mike Atherton,
Colin Cowdrey,
Geoff Boycott,
Ian Botham,
Graham Thorpe, i found it here friends !!
http://www.cricinfy.com/England-cricket-facts-history-future-achivements.html